• Get Listed
    • Get a FREE Quote for your Next Project
HardwareBee
https://promwad.com/
  • Find ASIC Vendors
  • Browse Design Services Directory
    • FPGA Design Services
    • Electronic Design Services
    • Embedded Software Companies
    • Add a Vendor
  • Get 5 Quotes From
    • FPGA Design Companies
    • Electronic Design Companies
    • Embedded Software Companies
    • Design & Manufacturing Vendors
  • WikiBee
  • Resources
    • FPGA Academy
    • Embedded Academy
    • FPGA vs ASIC Calculator
  • Get Free Consulting
  • Add a Vendor
HardwareBee
  • Browse Design Services Directory
    • FPGA Design Services
    • Electronic Design Services
    • Embedded Software Companies
    • Add a Vendor
  • Get 5 Quotes From
    • FPGA Design Companies
    • Electronic Design Companies
    • Embedded Software Companies
    • Design & Manufacturing Vendors
  • WikiBee
  • Resources
    • FPGA Academy
    • Embedded Academy
    • FPGA vs ASIC Calculator
  • Get Free Consulting
  • Add a Vendor
2381 Views

Choosing the Right FPGA for the Right Price

25/09/2018, hardwarebee

20 years ago, I was an FPGA developer in a large company, where we developed high speed wireless systems. The product consisted of several boards and every board had 3-5 FPGAs. FPGA unit price was always a big issue for us. Our sales people were pushing to lower the product cost, while the marketing folks wanted better performance (speed) and hence pushed for more costly FPGAs.

 

Two decades have passed and not much has changed. I am still involved in numerous discussions on how to choose the right FPGA that meets both price and performance goals, so I have decided to write down some guidelines that I have been using – hoping that it’ll help others struggling with similar dilemma.

 

Like with any other product, there are expensive and cheap FPGAs. Some of the more expensive FPGA’s can replace an entire system, letting you combine many different functionalities such as CPUs, high speed interfaces, digital blocks into a single chip. At the other end, there are cheap FPGAs that perform small tasks such as glue logic.

 

When discussing FPGA price, take into account that it combines both FPGA development costs and FPGA unit cost. In this article I will address the FPGA unit cost issue and how to make smarter decisions early on in the project phase.

 

Number of Input/Out Pins

 

When you draw your FPGA’s block diagram you will need to write down all the I/Os that your circuit requires. This is first input that will help you with the decision process, because if you need many I/Os – you will need a large FPGA.

 

If you are unsure, you can always start your design with a high I/O count FPGA and then when you get closer to production, try to lock all the pins and find a more suitable FPGA. Remember: a smaller FPGA means lower price. If you save even $1 per chip and your company sells 200K products per year, you’ve just saved your company $200K.

 

FPGA vendors have made our lives a bit easier. There are some FPGAs that overlap physical size and number of pins, therefore, allowing drop-in replacement of an FPGA that has same number of pins (and has more useable IOs). You can find an example below (Xilinx datasheet), where the table shows how “footprint compatible” chips provide users the freedom to go up or down the scale without changing the PCB layout.

 

 

Number of Gates

 

Number of Gates is a bit more difficult to estimate in the early stages, but as you progress with development, you will get more clarity about the number of gates. This is, of course, another key factor in the decision process.

 

Once you’ve nailed the gate number, the question left is how much headroom you should leave for future updates (or bug correction). One of the projects I have worked on had to go to production (and to customers) while knowing the FPGA code would need an update within a year. That’s one of the beauties of using an FPGA – field updates are possible.

 

If you are facing a similar dilemma, select an FPGA that is larger than the one that fits into the current design. It might be a waste of unused gates but will still be cheaper than field returns and recalls.

 

The following table shows Lattice’s MachXO2 FPGAs. You can see in the pink box how you could actually use the same package size, IOs and footprint to get higher or lower capacity FPGA. You could, for example, start the design with one FPGA type, layout the PCB and decide about the FPGA part number later on in the process.

 

 

FPGA Speed and Cost

 

Your FPGA implementation should meet your product specifications, therefore the questions related to which FPGA should you choose is highly depended on your design architecture. If you can choose an architecture that does not require a leading-edge FPGA, then you are lucky. But for me, I see FPGA speed and cost as given requirement.

 

Whenever I need FPGA price information I go to DigiKey, Farnell etc.

 

End of Life

 

When you are around for so many years you encounter a few End-of-Life cases. This means that the FPGA vendor is stopping the production of an FPGA chip due to different reasons. There is no real method to avoid this unfortunate situation. But there are ways to reduce the chances that your particular chip will be the victim.

 

First, always choose an FPGA family that is not more that 4-5 years old. Try to use the newest technologies if possibly. This will guarantee long(er) life time. Old chip will be based on mature wafer technology and 10 years from now the silicon fab may shut down the production line.

 

Secondly, look for pin compatibility (mentioned already above, I know). If you can find an FPGA that is pin compatible with other FPGAs, then you have a back up in case of End-of-Life.

linked in icon
Sign up for HardwareBee
* = required field

Recent Stories

What is the Principle of an Electric Motor
What is the Principle of an Electric Motor
Introduction to Thyristors
Introduction to Thyristors
Top Three Suppliers Held 94% of 2021 DRAM Marketshare
Top Three Suppliers Held 94% of 2021 DRAM Marketshare
Understanding Full-Wave Rectifiers
Understanding Full-Wave Rectifiers
Working Principle of a Transformer
Working Principle of a Transformer
Understanding Quiescent Current
Understanding Quiescent Current
Understanding Transimpedance Amplifier
Understanding Transimpedance Amplifier
Understanding Sample and Hold Circuit
Understanding Sample and Hold Circuit
Get 3 Quotes from Electronic Design Companies
Get 3 Quotes from FPGA Design Companies
Get 3 Quotes from Embedded SW Services
Get 3 Quotes from EMS Companies

Find Design Services

Get Price Offers From
  • Electronic Design Services
  • FPGA Design Services
  • Embedded Software Companies
  • PCB Layout Services
  • Printed Circuit Board Manufacturers
  • Design & Manufacturing Services
Welcome New Vendors
  • IDW Innovation Studio
  • Micro Technology Services
  • Byte Lab
  • Orthogone Technologies
  • Faststream Technologies
Answer a Question
  • Tips For Installing a PCB Prototype Board
  • Benefits of Working With a Reliable Flex Printed Circuit Board Manufacturer
  • FPGA company gross margin?
  • What is an FPGA used for?
  • When was FPGA invented
Recent WikiBee Items
  • FPGA Logic Analyzer
  • FPGA vs. ASIC Cost
  • FPGA Bitstream
  • VHDL
  • Transimpedance Amplifier
Recent Posts
  • What is the Principle of an Electric Motor
  • Introduction to Thyristors
  • Top Three Suppliers Held 94% of 2021 DRAM Marketshare
  • Understanding Full-Wave Rectifiers
  • Working Principle of a Transformer
Most Popular Blog Posts
  • Embedded Academy
  • Firmware and Embedded Software Development Services
  • IoT Software Development Company
  • Embedded Software Company
  • Firmware Development

Never miss an update!

Follow us on LinkedIn

Do you need any price
information?

(Electronic design, FPGA design, Embedded SW services, PCB design, Turnkey)

Yes
No
HardwareBee

Copyright 2017-2022, HardwareBee. All rights reserved.

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • Get Free Support
  • Get listed
  • Send a wiki/article
  • Advertise

Follow Us

Be sure to follow our LinkedIn company page where we share our latest updates LinkedIn
Partner with us Partner with us

Design and Manufacturing Services

  • Engineering Design Services
  • Electronic Design and Manufacturing
  • Electronic Product Development
  • Electronic Product Design
  • Electronic Consulting Services
  • Electronic Engineering Companies
  • Electronic Engineering Services
  • Electronic Product Design and Development
  • Electronics Design Services
  • Electronics Design Company
  • Electronic Design Consultants
  • Electronic Design Company
  • FPGA Design Company
  • FPGA Consultant
  • FPGA Design Services UK
  • Electronics Manufacturing services
  • Electronics Manufacturing Companies
  • Electronic Contract Manufacturing Companies
  • Electronic Manufacturing Services Companies
  • EMS Companies Directory
  • Electronic Design Services
  • FPGA Design Services
  • Embedded Software Companies
  • PCB Layout Services
  • Printed Circuit Board Manufacturers
  • Design and Manufacturing Services